Confident Calm Clutch
Confident, Calm & Clutch Blog/Car Ride Conversations/Cut, Benched or Not Recruited? How Athletes Handle What They Can’t Control

Cut, Benched or Not Recruited? How Athletes Handle What They Can’t Control

Sunday, September 20, 2026

Navigating the Uncontrollable in Sports: Embracing Effort and Resiliency







In the realm of sports, effort and dedication do not always lead to the desired outcomes, a lesson that every athlete must learn at some point. Athletes can practice for countless hours, perform at their peak, and still find themselves benched, unrecruited, or not picked. This stark reality begs the question of how athletes can maintain motivation when so much of their fate seems outside of their control.



Effort vs. Outcome



It's a common belief that relentless effort will inevitably lead to success. However, in sports, external factors like decisions made by coaches and the sheer unpredictability of games often dictate outcomes beyond one's control. Despite this, effort remains a significant factor—it's just not an outright guarantee of success. Real mental toughness, therefore, is measured by one's ability to continue striving even when outcomes aren't favorable.



Controlling the Controllables



The concept of "controlling the controllables" invites athletes to focus on elements within their power, such as preparation and attitude. But what's equally essential is understanding and accepting that certain things are beyond control, like other athletes' talents or a coach's decisions. Defining your self-worth through controllable factors allows for healthier motivation and resilience.



Separating Influence from Control



Athletes are encouraged to separate what they can control from what they can only influence and what they must accept. For example, while playing time is ultimately a coach’s decision, athletes can influence it with their preparation and attitude. Understanding these nuances helps athletes allocate their energy wisely and build optimism and well-being, regardless of final outcomes.



The Power of Accurate Thinking



Aiding athletes in recognizing what they own in situations is crucial. When facing disappointment, it’s important to discern between what could be improved upon and elements that are immutable. The aim is developing realistic optimism—not superficial positivity, encouraging athletes to take ownership without absorbing all the blame.



Realistic Pathways to Success



While it’s important to foster lofty dreams, athletes should also be encouraged to keep an open mind to alternate routes should their primary objective become unattainable. Just as GPS recalibrates routes amidst roadblocks, athletes too should adapt and explore different pathways to find meaningful accomplishments.



Embracing Disappointment and Building Resilience



Disappointment is an inevitable aspect of pursuing sports, and feeling it fully is part of processing it effectively. Athletes must learn to accept their emotions, examine what can be learned, and decide on actionable steps moving forward. Meanwhile, parents and coaches should allow space for this emotional processing, aiding their young athletes in learning resilience from such experiences.



Conclusion



Success in sports doesn’t just hinge on talent or effort alone, but rather in how effectively athletes manage the unexpected and uncontrollable. Encouraging athletes to own their process, accept what they cannot change, and re-route when necessary fosters not just better athletes, but mentally robust individuals ready to face whatever life throws at them.



Tune In for More




To dive deeper into these concepts and hear personal stories and expert insights, listen to the full episode of "Car Ride Conversations for Sports Families." Whether you're an athlete seeking to refine your mental toughness or a parent looking to support your child's sports journey, this podcast is an invaluable resource.

​

pexels-nitin-khajotia-1486064_clipped_rev_1 1 png

Hi, I Am ValErie Alston

Certified Mental Performance Consultant

Resilience Trainer and Performance Expert for the Army

Author

Former D1 Softball Player

Crossfit Enthusiast

Avid Traveler and lover of food

And Awesome Auntie!